Personalized Sports Balls - Made to Order


Let your team spirit take a bite out of the competition with these delicious personalized sports balls! Show your favorite sports team some love with these cookies that are sure to be a slam dunk at your next event. (Gimme a "YAY!")

Pricing is per single cookie. To personalize your cookie(s), include either name or number (or both), separated by commas. E.g. "32, 6, 0" or "Bob, Sue, Mark" or "Bob 32, Sue 6, Mark 0"

Please use the color selector to choose the color for the personalization. If no personalization is desired, choose any color and write "none" in the personalization box. Colors may vary slightly from the swatches. We are unable to accommodate any further customizations or colors. 

Please be sure to choose the date your cookies are needed in the date picker below. Orders can be picked up in store, or delivered to you for an additional fee! 


Pick Up Information


Made to order sweets require a 7-day notice as everything is baked, decorated, and packaged according to your needs. Please select your pick up/delivery date above.


Your order will be ready at opening time on your selected day, your order willl be on our pick up table inside the front door. Delivery now available via Favor for an additional fee.


When wrapped, or in an air tight container, Cookies stay fresh a minimum of 1 week at room temperature. Cake pops stay fresh for 2-3 days at room temperature, 5-7 in the fridge. Both can also be frozen for up to 6 months.


To ensure emails related to your order don't end up in spam/junk mail please add "" to your address book.